News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Heat on candidates to tackle some big issues 

Heat on candidates to tackle some big issues

23 Nov, 2009 10:13 AM
CANDIDATES for the Higgins by-election debated climate change at a forum last Wednesday.

Families Facing Climate Change hosted the forum at Glen Eira Uniting Church for the Higgins by-election which covers some Monash homes in Hughesdale.

Despite promising to show up, Liberal candidate Kelly O'Dwyer failed to complete a questionnaire or attend.

Two stand-out candidates were Clive Hamilton (Greens) and David Collyer (Australian Democrats), who were well versed on climate change and promised "serious action" to tackle the problem.

Fiona Patten (Australian Sex Party) and Joseph Toscano (an independent anarchist) understood less of the science behind climate change but were able to clearly spell out their policies.

Stephen Murphy (an independent climate sceptic) denied climate change was occurring at all. He claimed more investigation was needed.

Peter Brohier (independent) and Steve Raskovy (One Nation) agreed action should be taken but did not have clear policies on the issue.

Isaac Roberts (Liberal Democrats) and John Mulholland (Democratic Labor Party) also failed to attend.

Mr Hamilton, who wrote his first paper on climate change in 1994, said the Greens would cut emissions by 40per cent by 2020 and help those who might suffer in the transition.

Mr Collyer said, given what was currently known about climate change, if nothing was done the results could be "catastrophic" but said even if the research was wrong there was no harm in changing our power source.

He promised to keep an excise tax off alternative fuels and introduce an emissions trading policy that included agriculture.

Mr Murphy would call for more independent research on the topic and said there was "absolutely zero correlation between bushfires and climate change".

He said there had been no principal research on climate change and claimed there had been no mean increase in temperatures since 2002.

"Global warming has ended and we're actually reaching a period of global cooling."

Mr Toscano would "tax the polluters out of existence" and pay for sustainable energy solutions by ending tax exemption and benefits towards churches, private schools and private health care. Ms Patten promised prompt action.

"We've been debating this for many years but it just seems to continue when we really should be taking action. We need to get politicians to look past the political cycle."

FFCC spokeswoman Jane Morton said Mr Hamilton and Mr Collyer were "serious about addressing the climate crisis".

The Higgins by-election is on December5.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Great to see the Democrats in the mix giving middle Australia another option !
Posted by Max, 24/11/2009 4:54:56 PM, on Monash Weekly
Whether one is a believer or sceptic, all the discussion about global warming, climate change, ETS are nothing more than just talk fests, trying to prevent or slow down further deterioration of the climatic conditions.

In concurrence to all these debates and discussions, researches on global cooling should be funded to help reverse the trend. We must think outside the square, and release the trapped warm air to higher layers of the atmosphere, or improve air exchanges. Greedy opportunists and hoaxers on climate change are no different from the Y2K vultures, making millions and billions on human fallacy and frailty. Why pay other countries to grow trees, to green the earth, while we, the hypocrites keep polluting the environment? It is too much to ask the candidates to tackle big issues; the only big issue they all have in common is to the win the election by saying things that the voters like to hear. Unfortunately, they have no concept of looking at "big pictures". By the way, ETS may be aptly represents "Environmental Trickery Scam"!

Posted by Sin Fong Chan, 25/11/2009 9:41:43 PM, on Monash Weekly
Is Kelly O'Dwyer avoiding the press? I can't find any forum or article where she articulates her views or what she stands for. I've been bombarded by her glossy flyers; one of which declares her concern for our environment. But if she doesn't show up for community meetings, how concerned can she be? Could someone point me to an interview she's done so I can decide whether to vote for this "sure fire winner"?
Posted by Andrew, 29/11/2009 12:06:02 PM, on Monash Weekly
Excellent article, Kirsten Leiminger! It's great to see a thorough report of the various candidates' positions and policies - or their lack! It's also useful to know that one candidate didn't care enough to either answer or appear. That candidate shouldn't be surprised, then, if voters don't care to vote for her. Finally, the evaluation implicit in the assessment of two candidates being "well versed on climate change" is something we rarely see today in local reporting - the objective exercise of the reporter's judgment to help readers separate the wheat from the chaff, without the partisanship we expect from a committed editorial. Nice to know that some reporters, at least, understand their craft well enough to discharge their duty to the reading public admirably. Well done!, and more power to your pen (or maybe that should be, to your fingers on the keyboard)!
Posted by Yoyo, 30/11/2009 1:58:39 PM, on Monash Weekly
Glad to see some candidates taking the environment issue seriously. I heard that Messrs Collyer and Hamilton have also been endorsed by the Climate Emergency Network. Even better news for Higgins voters is that David Collyer is moderate, socially progressive and local!
Posted by Paul, 2/12/2009 10:08:10 PM, on Monash Weekly

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Fiona Patten:  Need to get politicians to look past the political cycle.   Picture: Suzanne Carbone/The Age
Fiona Patten: Need to get politicians to look past the political cycle. Picture: Suzanne Carbone/The Age
Kelly O'Dwyer: No questionnaire, no show.  Picture: Wayne Taylor/The Age
Kelly O'Dwyer: No questionnaire, no
show. Picture: Wayne Taylor/The Age
Clive Hamilton: Greens would cut emissions by 40per cent. Picture: Michael Clayton-Jones/The Age
Clive Hamilton: Greens would cut emissions by 40per cent. Picture: Michael Clayton-Jones/The Age
Steve Raskovy: Some action should be taken, but what? Picture: Rob Carew
Steve Raskovy: Some action should
be taken, but what? Picture: Rob Carew

Most popular articles




Monash Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...